Should You Get Dog Insurance? 4 Simple Steps to Decide


Whether or not to get insurance for your dog is a big financial decision. In this article, I will combine my knowledge and some information received from a licensed veterinarian to help you decide and find the cheapest one for your needs.

Dog owners not able or willing to spend a few thousand dollars at any time for their dog’s health should get pet insurance to avoid making decisions based on their ability to afford care. Otherwise, it depends on the likelihood that the dog could have health issues and the owner’s risk aversion.

There is no way to know for sure if dog insurance will be worth it. Nobody can predict the future medical costs of your dog. But there are ways to get more information and make a better decision based on simple facts detailed below.

Taking a few minutes to read this article is an excellent idea for two reasons. First, it could save you thousands of dollars. But mostly, it is written with the well-being of your dog in mind.

Before & After you Get your Puppy (eBooks)
+ Our Dog Supplies Checklist
+ Discounts & Coupons
FOR FREE

Step 1: Personal finances and dog medical costs

Having a dog is expensive. Throughout your pet’s lifetime, you will most probably spend over $10,000 in regular expenses (dog, supplies, food, vet, grooming, training), and it could even add up to more than $100,000. To get an idea of the cost of your favorite breed, you can check our breed-specific cost articles and make sure you can afford to raise a four-legged friend.

On top of that, your dog could need expensive medical treatments after an accident or because of an illness. Here are the 13 most common medical problems according to our consulting licensed veterinarian, Leslie Brooks, DVM. I have asked her opinion on 151 types of dogs (purebred and mixed-breeds) to establish this list.

The first column is the name of the medical problem. The second column is the percentage of dog breeds for which it was considered a risk. The third column is a cost estimate to treat this problem (can vary depending on many factors).

ConditionBreeds at RiskCost Estimate
Allergies53%$100 – $2,000 per year
Dental disease39%$400 – $800
Patellar luxation39%$300 – $2,000
Cancer29%$500 – $10,000
Hip dysplasia26%$500 – $6,500 per hip
Cranial cruciate ligament24%$2,000 – $4,000
Gastric dilatation-volvulus22%$1,500 – $3,000
Mitral valve disease (heart)20%$300 – $2,000
Hypothyroidism19%$350 – $800
Cataracts14%$1,500 – $3,000
Epilepsy13%$500 – $2,500
Arthritis13%$50 – $500 per month
Elbow dysplasia11%$2,000 – $3,500

As you can see, some medical conditions can be expensive to treat. Although purebred dogs may have a higher incidence of inherited disorders, mixed breed dogs are also likely to develop health conditions, such as cancer and heart disorders. No dog owner should have to make critical decisions about their pets based on their ability to afford care. That’s why pet insurance is more popular every year in the US.

It’s hard to put a definitive number, but it would seem wise to get dog insurance for anyone who would struggle to get access to at least $3,000 to $5,000 of savings at any time in case of an emergency. Not only do they need to have this amount of money, but they must also be ready to spend it on their dog.

If you are in this situation and agree with this, you can directly scroll down to step 3 to read a few tips to find the best and cheapest insurance for you. Otherwise, go to the second step below.

Step 2: Evaluate the risk of potential medical problems

If you are still reading, it’s that you feel confident that you could pay for your dog’s healthcare in case of an accident or severe illness. Now, the idea is to try to figure out the probability that dog insurance is cheaper (or more expensive) than medical expenses for your dog over time.

Let’s be honest, if there were a way to get this information with certainty, we would know it by now, and the pet insurance industry would not exist anymore. Nonetheless, there are a few ways to get some very interesting facts from different sources to help with the decision making process.

PetBudget directory

This blog started with the idea of evaluating the cost of owning different breeds of dogs. It allowed me to work with veterinarians to identify some of the most common possible medical problems for each dog breed and get a cost estimate to treat them.

You can go to our breed directory page, click on your favorite(s) breed(s), and get great information in the medical cost section. Once it’s done, come back to this article.

Health conditions DNA test

There is a way to evaluate the risk of many genetic health conditions to start preventive care early on and plan for potential significant expenses.

Along with Cornell University, Embark‘s veterinarians have developed a DNA test kit that enables them to evaluate the risk of over 190 health conditions. For less than $200, and within 2 to 5 weeks, you will receive a detailed report with great information to plan for proactive care with your veterinarian and budget your expenses. Embark is the most accurate and comprehensive dog DNA test on the market. It also tests for over 350 dog breeds.

Investing this amount is worth it, not only for your dog but also because it gives precious information to have when it’s time to make a decision that could result in thousands of dollars in expenses.

Talk to a veterinarian

Once this is done, you will already have a good idea of your dog’s level of health risk. The last action to take is to speak with a veterinarian about that. The idea is to answer three questions:

  • Are there any other potential medical conditions you should be aware of?
  • How much would each medical problem cost to treat?
  • Based on all this information, would the vet recommend getting pet insurance or not? (it’s good to have a professional opinion as well)

I know vet appointments can be expensive, and it doesn’t necessarily make financial sense to go just for that. If that’s what stops you, you can get instant answers with telehealth services. Airvet is an excellent alternative, for example. Download the free app, and Airvet will connect you with a vet in no time, 24/7.

It would cost $30 to speak to a veterinarian right now but could be cheaper if you are willing to wait, and you can keep chatting with the vet for up to 72 hours after the initial contact at no extra cost for any needed follow-up.

You now have the first side of your equation. Again, it’s not perfect, but it’s probably the most accurate information anyone can have.

Read our article titled a veterinarian explains medical costs for a dog to learn more and get tips to save on vet expenses.

Step 3: Dog insurance cost

The third step is to find the cost of pet insurance for your dog and needs. But first, I want you to have a better understanding of what’s available on the market.

A few facts about pet insurance

There are over 2 million dogs insured in the US only, and this number has been growing at a rate of 15% on average over the past few years.

There are three types of coverage:

  • Accident (like foreign body ingestion, lacerations, car accident, ligament tears, poisoning, etc.)
  • Accident and illness (accident benefits plus illnesses such as cancer, infections, digestive problems, etc.)
  • Complete health coverage (accident, illness, and most vet expenses like vaccinations, diagnostics, dental care, etc.)

Accident-only policies account for less than 1% of the US market, so they are not very popular.

According to the North American Pet Health Insurance Association’s latest industry report:

The average dog insurance premium in the US is $194 per year ($16 monthly) for accident-only policies and $585 per year ($49 monthly) for accident and illness. The price will vary depending on multiple factors, including the dog’s breed, age, location, and the plan chosen.

When comparing pet insurances, the cost is a significant factor, but it is also essential to consider the following aspects:

  • Deductible type (per incident or per year) and amount (usually $50 to $1,000)
  • Reimbursements percentage (usually 70 to 90%) and limits (could be $1,000 to unlimited)
  • Services included (diagnostic, follow-up exams, emergency visits, vaccines, hospitalization, surgery, medications, specialists, cancer treatments, pre-existing conditions, etc.)
  • Waiting times (policy coverage can start immediately or 14 days after sign up, accidents coverage could begin as late as 15 days after the policy starts and illnesses coverage as late as 30 days after, for example)
  • Dog’s age limit

I cannot stress enough how vital understanding all this is. Many people believe they have coverage for something when they don’t or underestimate the part they have to pay.

Pre-existing conditions are not just based on your dog but can also be based on the breed. It’s crucial because you might have to take some risks yourself, even if you have dog insurance.

Also, it’s good to know that you will have to pay the vet bills in full and wait for reimbursement from the insurance company in many cases. Some companies will also calculate the reimbursement based on the usual cost of vet care in your area instead of the actual price paid (if it’s too much).

Finally, some pet insurances don’t work with all vets. For example, a company can require that the vet taking care of your dog be a member of the American Veterinary Medical Association (AVMA). But your vet could have joined the Humane Society Veterinary Medical Association (HSVMA) instead.

I understand that all of this can be a headache, but it’s worth taking the time to inform yourself to avoid any bad surprises.

Find the best price

There isn’t a magic recipe to find the best price. But the process is straightforward. For accident only or accident and illness plans, the fastest way to get multiple quotes is by using websites like PetInsurer.com or PetInsuranceReview.com. You could also ask for quotes from other pet insurance companies that did not appear in the results. If you want to do that, I have listed most of the companies selling pet insurance in the US at the bottom of the article.

A little tip I use myself is always to double-check the best price I got from an insurance reseller with the price on the insurance company’s website.

Unless you go with Eusoh, with whom the monthly cost is capped (see below), premiums will increase as your dog gets older. So get quotes for different ages of your dog to get a better idea of the total cost you will have to pay over the years.

It’s also possible to get a price from insurance companies for complete health coverage, but the rates usually prohibitive. Routine vet expenses per year and dog on average being just north of $210, according to the American Pet Products Association (APPA)

The good news is that there is a fantastic alternative on the market: Eusoh. It’s my favorite solution, all dog insurance and coverage included. A remarkable fact is that Eusoh members pay $40 per month on average for complete health coverage. Compared to an accident & illness policy from a pet insurance company, which costs $49 per month on average, it’s a great deal. In most cases, you get more for less with Eusoh.

Community coverage VS Insurance

Eusoh: Better than Pet Insurance for Complete Health Coverage
Eusoh is a community-based pet insurance alternative in which members share the cost of their veterinary expenses. You get reimbursed for your pet’s medical, wellness, illness, routine care expenses but never pay more than $65/month.

For complete health coverage at a low cost, Eusoh is the best option. On average, members save around 50% when compared to traditional pet insurance. I love the idea of not having to worry about being able to afford medical care for my furry companion. Dogs are family, after all!

– There is no premium, so you don’t overpay for care in your monthly contributions. Any unused contributions are rolled over entirely as a credit.
– You can easily know in advance what will be reimbursed and by how much (usually 80%), and you can submit expenses easily from your smartphone.
– You can choose the veterinarian or healthcare provider you want and are covered for a wider range of services.
– You can get advice from other Eusoh members.

Once you have found what seems to be the best price and option for you, make sure to understand the deductibles, reimbursement percentage and limits. Also, check the services included (especially what is considered a pre-existing condition for your dog and your dog’s breed) and when the policy starts. If you have any doubt, contact the company.

Step 4: Make a decision

Now you have a lot of information to make a decision based on facts. Ask yourself the following questions.

Question 1: Do you have savings (at least three to five thousand), and would you be comfortable spending a few hundreds or thousands of dollars for your dog if needed?

If the answer is yes, go to question 2, otherwise you should get pet insurance.

Question 2: Should your dog need medical care because of a potential illness found during step 2, would it be cheaper to pay the medical bills yourself than to have enrolled in pet insurance?

Run a few scenarios based on the information collected in the two previous steps. Compare the cost estimate for any health issue that the dog could have versus the cost of pet insurance for the dog’s lifetime plus deductibles and coinsurance (the percentage of costs you pay after you’ve met your deductible).

If it is likely to be cheaper to buy pet insurance than to pay yourself if the dog gets one or two health problems (especially the ones where the risk is high for your dog or its breed), you should get pet insurance (a policy that covers these risks!). Otherwise, you should be fine without one.

Final thoughts

If you don’t have many savings and would be facing a difficult decision if a vet announced to you that your dog needs expensive treatments, surgery, etc., it’s probably best to get dog insurance. Complete health coverage from Eusoh would probably be the way to go as it also includes vet visits and most expenses for a very reasonable price. An accident and illness plan from a pet insurance company could also work.

If you feel comfortable about your financial situation, but your dog seems to be at risk for any expensive medical condition, do some scenarios to evaluate and compare your potential costs. Chances are it will make sense to get pet insurance (as long as these medical problems are covered). Your best options are either an accident and illness plan from the insurance company of your choosing or complete coverage from Eusoh.

Suppose you feel comfortable about your financial situation. After gathering all the information during step 2, it seems that your dog has an excellent chance to remain healthy his whole life. In that case, you can follow your initial idea. No pet insurance or a simple accident coverage could be OK (as an accident can always happen) since you could pay the medical bills if needed. But you can also buy peace of mind by getting better coverage.

If you love dogs, I would like to present to you our Dogs are Awesome! clothing line. I have partnered with TeeSpring to create a whole collection for dog enthusiasts willing to show it.

Our awesome clothing line includes premium quality t-shirts, tank tops, hoodies for men and women, baby onesies (and stickers). Many colors and breeds available. Treat yourself or offer it as the perfect gift!

More content you could like

Pet insurance providers in the US

Here is a list of most of the companies you can get pet insurance from in the US. If there is another name between parenthesis, it’s either the company they belong to or the company they partnered with to provide pet insurance.

  • ASPCA Pet Health Insurance (Crum & Forster)
  • Hartville Pet Insurance (Crum & Forster)
  • Liberty Mutual Pet Insurance (Crum & Forster)
  • PetPremium Pet Health Insurance (Crum & Forster)
  • Prudent Pet (Crum & Forster)
  • Spot Pet Insurance (Crum & Forster)
  • Allstate (Embrace)
  • American Family (Embrace)
  • American Modern (Embrace)
  • Armed Forces (Embrace)
  • Bolt Agency (Embrace)
  • Embrace
  • Geico (Embrace)
  • SWBC (Embrace)
  • USAA (Embrace)
  • Figo Pet Insurance
  • Healthy Paws Pet Insurance & Foundation
  • Nationwide Pet Insurance
  • PetFirst Pet Insurance
  • 24PetWatch (PetHealth)
  • AKC Pet Insurance (PetPartners)
  • PetPartners
  • Petplan Pet insurance
  • Farmers Insurance (Pets Best Insurance)
  • Pets Best Insurance
  • Progressive Insurance (Pets Best Insurance)
  • Trupanion

Johann Chapuis

Johann Chapuis has assembled a fantastic team of licensed veterinarians, animal behaviorists, dog trainers, groomers, and walkers to write every article and offer the most accurate content on petbudget.com. Being a pet lover and owner himself, Johann is sharing his experiences and his financial aptitude cultivated during his MBA with a specialization in finance and the numerous years he spent working as a business manager and entrepreneur.

Recent Posts